Construction Industry Federation says people are being turned off applying
Construction industry needs skilled workers to build houses.
Almost 10,000 work permits were granted to non-EU nationals in the first three months of this year, indicating that the numbers coming to work here will be far in excess of last year’s total. However, the figures show there is a shortage of workers in various sectors across the country.
The number granted permits for the first three months of this year reached 9,897, with 1,095 applications refused and 230 withdrawn.
The number of permits being granted has jumped massively from a low of 3,863 in 2013 as the recession reached its peak. Four years earlier in 2009, as the recession was starting to take hold, the total was 7,962.
In the construction industry workers from outside the EU are urgently needed to relieve the housing crisis due to the shortage of units being built compared to the demand. But they are currently being “delayed or turned off” coming to Ireland due to “a lack of synchronised efforts” by two government departments, an industry watchdog claims.
The claims have been made by the Construction Industry Federation (CIF), the sector’s representative body, even though the number of construction workers granted work permits from outside the EU for the first two months of this year has more than doubled compared to the same period in 2024.
Construction industry needs skilled workers to build houses. Photo: Andrew Aitchison
A total of 262 people were granted construction work permits in January, February and March last year, while 1,523 in total for 2024 were given the green light. For the first three months of this year, 577 construction work permits have so far been approved.
Sean Downey, director of the CIF’s learning and development department, said that despite efforts by the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment to fast-track their entry into the country, the requirement by the Department of Foreign Affairs for visas from countries outside of the EU is delaying the process by as much as four months.
“To us there seems to be no synchronised communication and work permit guidance between both departments. The Department of Foreign Affairs should be linking closer with Trade and Employment and construction companies which hold trusted employer status,” Mr Downey said.
“By having to wait four months to get a visa to work here, it is putting a lot of potential workers off coming to Ireland from such places as South ¬Africa.
“The Department of Trade held a very successful recruitment campaign there last year to encourage more skilled construction people to come here yet Foreign Affairs does not seem to be liaising with them. This obviously in return is impacting on housing units being built.”
The payroll data, based on tax paid by workers, put the number working in construction at 143,100 in June last year, up from 133,300 at the end of 2022. The most recent Labour Force Survey data puts the numbers employed in construction at 171,000 but the State needs tens of thousands more to meet housing and retrofitting 2030 targets.
Mr Downey said this is creating a “barrier” to getting a “very skilled” workforce from South Africa, China and Russia here to help with the crisis.
Mr Downey made his comments as the Department of Trade, Enterprise and Employment released figures for the first two months of this year to the Sunday Independent which show the numbers of non-EU workers being granted work permits still continues to rise year-on-year.
Of the work permits granted for ¬January and February 2,204 were ¬issued to the Indian community, 692 to Brazilians, 656 to those from the Philippines, 475 from China, 272 from South Africa and 46 from Russia.
The sectors where most foreign ¬nationals from outside the EU are employed are in construction and related industries, healthcare, agriculture and food, the service industries, technology and communication based companies.
Of the work permits granted for non-EU nationals in January and February this year, the highest numbers are based in Dublin with 3,295, with 550 in Cork and 297 in Kildare.
“It is not unusual to have people speaking 20 different languages on a construction site now. You have the first wave of EU nationals coming here in the early 2000s but perhaps weren’t that skilled in the industry,” Mr Downey said.
“They in turn are subcontracting work out to others from their own countries and are bringing multiples of workers here from countries such as Romania, Moldova and Poland. However, it needs to be reiterated that Irish workers are still in the majority but there are steady numbers coming here from both inside and outside the EU.”
A spokesperson for the Department of Trade, Enterprise and Employment said because of work permits not being needed by EU citizens it is “impossible” to ascertain the numbers of such nationalities working in construction and ancillary companies.
However, anecdotal evidence from large and small construction companies suggests thousands of workers are arriving from former Eastern Bloc countries such as Romania.
“Many construction firms will not publicly speak about issues employing foreign workers in case it impedes them,” said Mr Downey.